Is this Normal?

When you raise issues about Timberlane’s financials to the TRSD auditor, you get stony silence, even as a board member.  When you question a second time, you get threats from our SAU. I’ll leave you to decide if this is normal.

You should also know:

  1. Timberlane’s district treasurer resigned suddenly last week after four months in the position.   I have done a Right to Know request for her resignation email and everything else that went between her and the district..  Martha Sumner is a senior VP for a regional bank.  If anyone is capable of doing the district’s reconciliation with our bank accounts, it would be Ms. Sumner.
  2. SAU 55’s Business Administrator is not yet certified by the state as a school district business administrator.  He is on a “pathway to certification,” according to the Department of Education yesterday.
  3. SAU 55 does not have an Assistant Business Administrator, which we used to have. That position was re-titled as Business Operations Coordinator, and Mr. Tom Geary was hired.  Mr. Geary’s resume has not been made public but to my knowledge he does not have a Bachelor’s degree and he does not have an employment background in accounting or finance.
  4. Arthur Green and I sent an email to Timberlane’s auditors on Jan. 3, 2018 pointing out some issues in Timberlane’s 2016/17 financial statements (within the scope of the current annual audit).  No response from TRSD or Plodzik and Sanderson, PA.  In Feb we sent our email again via certified mail.  No answer from any party.
  5. Yesterday, Arthur Green and I sent out another email pointing out material financial reporting errors in the newly released TRSD annual report for 2016/17, as well as restating the issues previously raised.  We also sent this by certified mail to Plodzik and Sanderson, PA. Letter to Auditors March 2018 certified

SAU 55 finally broke their silence today with a barrage of threats.  This email was sent to me, Arthur Green and Superitendent Metzler, but not, notably, sent to the auditor.  Here is today’s email:

Dear Mr. and Mrs. Green,

 Please be advised this office has received communication from Plodzik and Sanderson requesting we notify you of the following:

 Plodzik & Sanderson, P.A. does not have an engagement with you. The next communication from you be it email, traditional mail, certified mail or phone call will trigger a consulting engagement with hourly rates of $250 and a minimum of 4 hours, for which under professional standards they will be prohibited from discussing another engagement or client.

 To be clear, if you trigger an engagement with Plodzik and Sanderson they will proceed with any legal actions necessary to collect fees associated with that engagement.

 This communication shall serve of notification that any further action will constitute engagement of the firm.  

 Thank you,

Cathy Belcher

Now don’t you find it interesting that SAU 55, the entity whose work is being audited, is threatening me?  Has the auditor lost his voice or fingertips?  Did the auditors even say such an outlandish thing? The email is cunningly written so I dare not call Plodzik, but I can assure you I will be making other calls.

By way of more background, another Timberlane resident, a former CPA no less, sent a letter to Plodzik and Sanderson, PA last year concerning issues in the Town of Plaistow’s audit and got a cease and desist letter in return Upton and Hatfield (3).

There is no known record of the last time Timberlane’s auditors were changed.




Filed under Sandown Issues

2 responses to “Is this Normal?

  1. Pingback: Donna Green: Is this Normal? | The New Media Militia

  2. Leon

    Timberlane Regional – Audit Shmaudit

    Timberlane has an auditing firm, Plodzik and Sanderson, they supply the Audit Report in the Timberlane Regional School District Annual Report – that thing in your lap at the Annual School Meeting’s in March.

    I heard some grumbling about a resignation by an official involved with the 2017 audit. It peaked my interest so took a brief look – starting with 2014 up until the one that is supposed to be ready now.

    If in 2014 Timberlane had an Auditor’s Report for the year 2013 – it isn’t in the Annual Report, check page #2, not there – no mention of one.…/2014-Annual-Report-Timberlane.p…

    If in 2015 Timberlane had an Auditor’s Report for the year 2014 – it isn’t in the Annual Report check page #2, not there, no mention of one.…/2015%20Annual%20Report%20-%…

    In 2016 Timberlane had an “Auditors Report” for the year 2015 it is listed on page #2 of the Annual Report.…/2016%20Annual%20Report%20-%…
    The “Auditors Report” is found in “Addendum B.”…/2015%20Timberlane%20-%20AUD…

    The 2017 Timberlane Annual Report for the year 2017 includes an “Auditors Status Letter” listed on page #2.…/2017-Annual-Report-Timberlane.p….

    The March 2, 2018 “Auditors Status Letter” is found on page #25 in the 2017 Annual Report.
    The “Auditors Status Letter” promises a completed audit “by the end of March.” That’s nice.

    Coach Metzler must be aware of: DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE ADMINISTRATION Municipal and Property Division, Section 21-J:19.
    That would be the law requiring financial audits of municipalities and schools.
    I will spare readers the entire text of the statute but there is this very important last sentence:

    “A written or printed report of every completed audit shall be made to the proper local officials including a summary of the findings and recommendations of the auditors and a copy of such summary shall be published in the next annual report following the fiscal year in which the audit was completed.”

    2013 – No auditor’s Report:…/Shared%20D…/ANNUAL%20REPORTS

    2012 – No Auditor’s Report:…/2012%20Annual%20Report%20-%…

    2011 – No Auditor’s Report:…/2011%20Annual%20Report%20-%…

    Didn’t Timberlane Regional School District have one of the most highly paid superintendent’s in the State of New Hampshire?
    The School Board must have higher priorities than simply printing an audit in the Annual Report.

    At least in 2018 taxpayers are promised one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s